Reading the Teeth
Getting the information you need
Dean F. Adams


I was beginning to form a lifelong habit: staring at both faces of every gear tooth in my race bike’s gearbox. And when I stared at the driving face of first pinion (the smallest gear on the input shaft) I saw something I didn’t understand. At about 2/3 of the way inward from tip to root, on every tooth was a gray line, parallel to the shaft axis. I pulled my 50X hand microscope from the toolbox, found a spot of good light and looked more closely. The gray line was made up of many tiny pits. They weren’t there when this gear was new.

The bike went racing again, and the pitting became worse. I decided to try other lubricants, based on the recommendations of experienced elders:

The service book listed 20/50 engine oil (this was a two-stroke engine)

Several people swore by ATF, watery red stuff that lubes the gears in automatic transmissions. It has a spicy smell, too.

I was assured by another advisor that Castrol R/40 was the solution.

My problem was that with all of these oils the same pitting resulted (new input shafts).

I tried them on new gears and pitting still occurred.

I had worked as a lab tech at MIT. I dressed up as a teaching assistant and walked into the great dome housing the Eng. Libe. The card catalog sent me to Dudley’s “Gear Handbook” and soon I was scribbling notes at a study table.

My problem was called “pitch-line pitting" and could have a variety of causes. Leverage was greatest for first pinion because its diameter is the smallest. In gearing for heavy trucks, I learned, tooth-to-tooth load could reach 100,000 psi. Under that load, the material tries to evade its responsibility by moving sideways, out from under the load. That, in turn, generated powerful shear forces just under the tooth surface – Hertz stress.

Next I found an explanation of how pits were formed on my gear teeth. All steels contain inclusions of oxides or other foreign matter. Their presence, combined with frequently repeated high stress, can nucleate a tiny crack. This, I learned, was because the inclusion was less strong than the metal around it, causing it to carry the inclusion’s share of the load. Stress concentration.

If such a crack propagated to the loaded surface at a small angle, the tip of the crack (a tiny thing) could break off, leaving a pit. Now I had the story to go with my evidence.

Dean F. Adams


Looking at my gears I suspected they had been manufactured by a satellite supplier, as their tooth surfaces weren’t as smooth as those of production gears. Maybe my gears had been cut using hobs too worn for further use in production?

Now came a leap: I learned that certain oil additives have a polishing action – Extreme Pressure (EP) additives. I found publications describing MIL-spec lubricants containing them.

I phoned a helo' operator out at Boston’s Logan airport, who brought me down to earth. “Yeah, we can’t find that MIL stuff either, so we just buy a case of ESSO Hypoy-90 rear end fluid. Works great.”

I did the same. It banished pitch-line pitting and my gears looked pretty good. That scary number – 90 – which seems to suggest power-robbing molasses, was nothing like that. I added a bit of moly disulfide dry lube powder, as at least one major automaker at the time was doing.

A couple of years later I saw that the maker of my race bike had experienced the same problem. Their race bike gear teeth were no longer as-hobbed, but were finished by grinding or shaving. That lovely surface finish, combined with the fact that a rider cannot unlock a seized gearbox with the clutch, made me see those new gears as objects of great functional beauty.

Modern four-stroke engines share their engine oil with the gearbox, so gear oils cannot be used. To allow engine oil to carry tooth-to-tooth gear loads, the gears are made larger in diameter to reduce such loads.

Dean F. Adams

MORE FROM KEVIN CAMERON ON SOUP

When Hard Became Soft at Motegi
When Superbikes Became Superbikes
Evolution of Yamaha Two-Stroke Cylinders
Motorcycle Myths & Nonsense Vol 1
The Air-Cooled Argument
Too Close to the Fire
Feeling the Boundary Layer
Curtains in the Sky: The Aurora

— ends —
Share on:
Hardscrabble
Garage
3
Superbike Planet